How to Choose the Best Mushroom Supplement: 5 Things to Look For
Share
Introduction
With the rising popularity of medicinal mushrooms like Lion’s Mane, Reishi, and Cordyceps, the supplement market is flooded with options. But not all mushroom supplements are created equal. This guide will help you identify the highest-quality mushroom products so you can get the most out of your supplements.
1. Look for Fruiting Body Extracts, Not Mycelium on Grain
✔ Best choice: Supplements made from fruiting bodies (the actual mushroom).
❌ Avoid: Products using mycelium on grain, which are often lower in beneficial compounds and higher in starch fillers.
Why It Matters:
-
Fruiting bodies contain higher concentrations of beta-glucans, the main active compounds.
-
Mycelium on grain is often not fully extracted, leading to weaker benefits.
2. Check for Dual-Extraction for Full-Spectrum Benefits
✔ Hot Water Extraction → Extracts beta-glucans (immune-supporting compounds).
✔ Alcohol Extraction → Extracts triterpenes & sterols (adaptogenic & brain-supporting compounds).
Why It Matters:
-
Reishi & Chaga need alcohol extraction for their adaptogenic properties.
-
Lion’s Mane & Cordyceps need hot water extraction for their brain-boosting and energy-enhancing compounds.
Best choice: Dual-extracted tinctures or powders that contain both water-soluble and fat-soluble compounds.
3. Look for a High Beta-Glucan Content
✔ Beta-glucans = the most important active compound in medicinal mushrooms.
❌ Avoid supplements that list “polysaccharides” instead of beta-glucans—polysaccharides can include starch fillers.
Why It Matters:
-
Beta-glucans support immunity, gut health, and inflammation reduction.
-
Quality products will list the beta-glucan percentage (ideally 20-50%) on the label.
4. Third-Party Testing for Purity & Quality
✔ Look for lab-tested supplements that are screened for:
-
Heavy metals
-
Pesticides
-
Contaminants
-
Proper beta-glucan content
Best choice: Brands that provide lab test results on their website.
5. Choose Organic & Sustainably Sourced Mushrooms
✔ Organic mushrooms are free from pesticides and harmful chemicals.
✔ Wild-harvested or log-grown mushrooms tend to have the highest nutrient content.
❌ Avoid grain-grown mushrooms that may contain high levels of starch.
Why It Matters:
-
Sustainably sourced mushrooms contain more beneficial compounds than artificially grown versions.
-
Organic certification ensures purity and safety.
Best Mushroom Supplement Types & Their Benefits
| Type of Supplement | Best For | Key Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Tinctures | Fast absorption & high potency | Look for dual-extracted formulas |
| Powders | Versatile & easy to mix | Best when extracted from fruiting bodies |
| Capsules | Convenient & easy to dose | Ensure high beta-glucan content |
Conclusion
If you want a high-quality mushroom supplement, look for: ✔ Fruiting body extracts (not mycelium on grain).
✔ Dual-extracted formulas for maximum benefits.
✔ High beta-glucan content (20-50%).
✔ Third-party lab testing for purity.
✔ Organic & sustainably sourced ingredients.
Looking for the Best Mushroom Supplements?
Consider a dual-extract tincture or powder from a trusted, lab-tested brand.
FAQs
Q: Are mushroom powders or tinctures better?
A: Tinctures absorb faster and are more concentrated. Powders are great for adding to drinks and meals.
Q: How can I tell if a mushroom supplement is high quality?
A: Check the label for fruiting body extract, dual-extraction, and beta-glucan content.
Q: Can I take multiple mushroom supplements together?
A: Yes! Many people combine Lion’s Mane for focus, Reishi for stress relief, and Cordyceps for energy.
Stay tuned for more medicinal mushroom buying guides and supplement reviews!